A low income guess used to cost $1,625. Now it costs all of it.
Open enrollment runs to January 15. Two rules changed underneath it: the 400% income cliff is back at $63,840 for one person, and the cap on paying a subsidy back is gone.
November 2, 2026 ยท 5 min read
Open enrollment opened Sunday. On HealthCare.gov you have until January 15 to pick a 2027 plan, and until December 15 if you want it to start January 1. KFF puts the average increase in benchmark silver premiums at 13% for 2027, 11% in HealthCare.gov states and 16% in the state-run exchanges, which stacks to a 42% rise since 2025. Those are the numbers in every headline this week.
Here is the one that is not. The riskiest box on the application is the one where you estimate next year's income, and two separate rules just made a wrong guess much more expensive. The 400% of poverty ceiling on eligibility is back, because the law that suspended it only covered tax years 2021 through 2025. And the IRS now says there is no repayment cap for tax years after 2025. For the 2025 tax year the most a single filer under that ceiling could be asked to pay back was $1,625. Starting with the 2026 tax year there is no ceiling on it at all.
$63,840 is a line, not a slope
The threshold is 400% of the federal poverty line for your household size. Coverage for 2027 runs off the 2026 HHS poverty guidelines, which put the 100% line at $15,960 for one person, $21,640 for two, $27,320 for three and $33,000 for four. Multiply by four and you have the numbers that actually decide things: $63,840, $86,560, $109,280 and $132,000. Alaska and Hawaii run on separate, higher schedules.
Land a dollar under and you get a premium tax credit. Land a dollar over and you get nothing. Not a smaller credit. Nothing. The IRS states the general rule plainly: you may be eligible if household income is at least 100% but no more than 400% of the federal poverty line. For tax years 2021 through 2025 Congress temporarily removed that ceiling and let the credit taper instead, so for five years a few extra dollars of income cost you a few dollars of credit. That arrangement expired with the 2025 tax year.
So this is a genuine cliff again, and cliffs reward precision. A freelancer who takes one more December invoice, a retiree who sells a fund in November, a household where somebody picks up fourth-quarter overtime: any of those can carry you over a line that looked comfortable in March.
The cap that used to absorb your mistake
Reconciliation is the part nobody reads about. The marketplace pays your credit in advance, monthly, straight to your insurer, based on the income you estimated. At tax time Form 8962 compares what was advanced against what you actually qualified for. Too little advanced and you get the difference back. Too much and you owe it.
Until now there was a ceiling on that bill. Table 5 of the 2025 Form 8962 instructions caps the repayment at $375 for a single filer under 200% of poverty and $750 for every other filing status, $975 and $1,950 between 200% and 300%, and $1,625 and $3,250 between 300% and 400%. At 400% or more there was never a cap. That gave the old system one soft edge: stay under 400% and your worst case was a known, survivable number.
That edge is gone. The IRS language leaves no room: there is no repayment cap for tax years after 2025, and for those years you must repay the full amount by which your advance credit payments exceed your premium tax credit. Work an example. A single filer has $4,800 advanced over the year but, on the actual numbers, qualifies for $2,000. The excess is $2,800. At 350% of poverty the old cap held that to $1,625. For tax year 2026 the bill is the whole $2,800.
Two different changes, landing on the same return. The cliff above 400% was always uncapped, and it is back after a five-year pause. The cap removal is new, and it hits everyone below the line. Most coverage blurs those together. They are worth keeping apart, because the second one reaches people who never go near 400%.
You can still move the number
What decides this is modified adjusted gross income, and some of that is still in your hands in December. A deductible contribution lowers it. A Roth contribution does not. That is the entire lever.
Run it. A single filer who lands at $64,500 is $660 over the line. Put $700 into a traditional 401(k) instead of the Roth side of the same plan and the number goes back under. If $4,800 of credit was riding on that $660, you paid $700 to keep $4,800, and you still own the $700. Traditional IRA and HSA contributions work the same way. Roth dollars do nothing here, because they never touch MAGI.
Two honest limits. It only works when you are close, so nobody deducts their way down from $90,000. And if you are self-employed and claiming the self-employed health insurance deduction, the math turns circular: the deduction depends on the credit and the credit depends on the deduction. The IRS sends you to Publication 974 for that, and it is a reasonable place to want an accountant.
Tell them when it changes, not in April
The marketplace will recalculate your advance payments mid-year, but only if you tell it to. The IRS is direct about why that matters: reporting a change in circumstances as soon as it happens lets the Marketplace adjust your advance payments, which cuts the chance of a significant difference at tax time. The triggers it names include increases in household income, lump-sum Social Security payments, marriage and divorce. A raise in July is a phone call in July.
While you are in there, do not let the renewal run itself. As of October 29, KFF counted 11 insurers leaving at least one state for 2027, with Cigna exiting the individual market in all 11 states where it sells. Effectuated marketplace enrollment was already down 12%, about 2.6 million people, to 19.2 million as of February 2026. If your carrier is one of the ones walking away, something automated is choosing your plan for you.
If you do end up owing, the IRS says it routinely works with taxpayers who cannot cover the balance at filing. Worth knowing. Not worth planning around.
Don't
- ๐ซEstimate your income low to get a bigger advance credit; for 2026 you repay every dollar of the excess
- ๐ซAssume landing just over 400% of poverty costs you a little, when it costs the whole credit
- ๐ซLet auto-renewal place you with a carrier that is leaving your state
Do
- โ Find your 400% line: $63,840 for one, $86,560 for two, $109,280 for three, $132,000 for four
- โ Call the Marketplace the month your income changes, not the April after
- โ If you will land just over, move the difference into a pre-tax account, not a Roth
The takeaway
Two rules changed at once. Above 400% of poverty the premium tax credit is zero rather than smaller, and for 2027 coverage that line sits at $63,840 for one person and $132,000 for a family of four. Below the line the repayment cap is gone starting with the 2026 tax year, the return you file next spring, so a low estimate now costs you the entire excess instead of the old $1,625 maximum for a single filer. The fix is boring and it works: estimate your income honestly, call the marketplace the month something changes rather than the April after, and if you are going to land just over the line, move the difference into a pre-tax account before December 31. Paying $700 to keep $4,800 is the best trade on this page.
Keep reading
Far Better Off is educational and not financial advice. Consider your own circumstances or a qualified professional for big decisions.