The 2027 FSA cap is $3,500. You can waste $1,038 of it and break even.

The 2027 FSA cap is $3,500. You can waste $1,038 of it and break even.

The IRS set next year's health FSA limit on November 5. Open enrollment is asking you for a number, and fear of the use-it-or-lose-it rule talks most people into one that is too small.

November 9, 2026 ยท 5 min read

The IRS published next year's numbers on November 5. In Revenue Procedure 2026-35 the dollar limit on salary reduction contributions to a health flexible spending arrangement goes to $3,500 for tax years beginning in 2027, up $100, and the maximum carryover goes to $700, up $20 from the $680 allowed for 2026. If your employer runs open enrollment this month, that is the box you are about to fill in.

Almost nobody fills it in near the cap. The Employee Benefit Research Institute looked at more than 3.3 million accounts holding more than $3.9 billion of contributions and found the average 2024 election was $1,431, about 41% of next year's cap. The reason is the rule everybody knows: money left in the account at the end goes back to your employer. EBRI found about 40% of accountholders forfeited something in 2024, an average of $404 each. That sounds like an argument for electing less. Do the arithmetic and it is mostly an argument for electing more, because the question is not whether you will forfeit. It is how much you can forfeit before the account stops paying you.

An FSA dollar dodges a tax your 401(k) dollar does not

IRS Publication 969 puts it in one line: you do not pay federal income tax or employment taxes on the salary you contribute. The first half is familiar. The second half is the part that gets skipped, and it is where the money is.

A traditional 401(k) deferral escapes income tax and then pays Social Security and Medicare anyway. IRS Topic No. 751 sets the employee share of those at 6.2% and 1.45%, so 7.65% comes out of a 401(k) dollar and does not come out of an FSA dollar. Stack that on a 22% federal bracket and an FSA dollar saves you 29.65 cents. Most states follow the federal treatment, which widens it further.

So price the full election. $3,500 at 29.65% hands back $1,037.75. You give up $2,462.25 of take-home pay and you get $3,500 of medical spending. In the 12% bracket the combined rate is 19.65% and the election returns $687.75. Nothing else in open enrollment pays like that, and it pays on money you were going to spend at the pharmacy regardless.

The break-even is a percentage, and it is your tax rate

Here is the part the use-it-or-lose-it warnings never tell you. Electing zero is not the safe choice, it is just a different choice, and it costs you that 29.65 cents on every medical dollar. So the real test is a comparison: at what point does a forfeiture eat the whole tax break?

The answer is clean. You break even when the amount you forfeit equals the tax you saved, which means you can throw away your combined marginal rate and come out level. In the 22% bracket that is 29.65% of whatever you elect. On a $3,500 election you can forfeit $1,037.75 and still be exactly as well off as the person who elected nothing. In the 12% bracket the cushion is 19.65%, or $687.75.

Now put EBRI's average forfeiture next to that. $404 is 11.5% of a $3,500 election, comfortably inside the cushion at either bracket. EBRI says so itself: workers may still benefit when their tax savings exceed the amount forfeited. And the trend is going the right way. The $404 average was down from $436 in 2023 and, adjusted for inflation, the lowest EBRI has recorded since it built the database in 2019.

Your plan has one of three endings. Go find out which

HealthCare.gov is blunt about the default: at the end of the year or grace period, you lose any money left over in your FSA. What softens that is an option your employer picks, and there are exactly two. A grace period gives you up to two and a half extra months to spend last year's balance. A carryover moves up to $700 of it into 2028. Your employer does not have to offer either, and when it does offer one, it can be either one of these options but not both.

That gives you three possible endings: a hard December 31, a grace period running into mid-March, or a $700 carryover. Which one you have changes the election a lot. With the full carryover, the first $700 you fail to spend is not forfeited at all, so on a $3,500 election in the 22% bracket you would have to leave $1,737.75 unspent before you lost a dollar. That is 49.65% of the election. You have to misjudge your own medical spending by half.

One more number worth knowing before you pick: the limit applies per employer. If you and a spouse each have an FSA through your own job, you each get $3,500, so a couple can shelter $7,000 in 2027. Nothing about the household limit halves it.

Two ways this actually goes wrong

The first is that the election is locked. Publication 969 says you can change or revoke your election only if specifically allowed by law and the plan, which in practice means a qualifying life event or nothing. An HSA lets you adjust as the year goes. An FSA does not. That is the real reason to be conservative, and it argues for electing what you can see coming rather than what you hope to need.

The second one is expensive and quiet. If you are covered by a high deductible health plan and contributing to an HSA, Publication 969 says someone with an HDHP and a health FSA cannot generally make contributions to an HSA. A general purpose health FSA can therefore cost you the better account, because HSA money has no deadline at all. Limited purpose arrangements for dental and vision, and post-deductible arrangements, do not create that conflict. If you have an HSA, that distinction is the whole decision.

If you are already holding a balance this December, spend it on the list that got longer and stayed that way. The IRS says the CARES Act made over-the-counter products and medications reimbursable without a prescription, and menstrual care products reimbursable too, for amounts paid after December 31, 2019. Keep the receipts. And note where the forfeitures actually cluster: EBRI found two-thirds of accountholders under 25 forfeited something, against 36% of those 65 and older. That gap looks less like bad forecasting than like unfiled claims.

Don't

  • ๐ŸšซElect the minimum out of fear of the use-it-or-lose-it rule; the break-even is your tax rate, not zero
  • ๐ŸšซAssume you have a carryover or a grace period, when your plan can have one and can have neither
  • ๐ŸšซElect a general purpose health FSA while you are contributing to an HSA

Do

  • โœ…Price the election at your combined rate: 22% plus 7.65% FICA returns 29.65 cents on the dollar
  • โœ…Ask HR one question: hard December 31, two and a half month grace period, or $700 carryover
  • โœ…Claim both $3,500 elections if you and your spouse each have an FSA at work

The takeaway

The use-it-or-lose-it rule is real, and it is smaller than the fear of it. The 2027 cap is $3,500, and in the 22% bracket that election hands back $1,037.75, which is also the amount you can forfeit before you are worse off than the person who elected nothing. If your plan carries $700 forward, the number becomes $1,737.75, or roughly half the election. The average forfeiture is $404. So elect what you honestly expect to spend, add the carryover if you have one, and then ask HR which of the three endings your plan uses, because that is the only part of this you cannot look up yourself.

๐ŸงฎSee what a pre-tax dollar does to your checkFree ยท no sign-up ยท try it with your own numbers

Keep reading

Far Better Off is educational and not financial advice. Consider your own circumstances or a qualified professional for big decisions.